The average yearly salary for Private School Teacher in Chicago, Illinois is $38,005. If you are just beginning to work a new job as a Private School Teacher in Chicago, Illinois, you could earn a starting pay rate of $31,299 annually. As is true for most jobs and careers, you can expect your hourly pay rate or salary to increase as you gain experience and the longer you are employed with the same employer. In Chicago you could potentially make an average income of around $44,712 after several years on the job with increased wages. When pursuing your career of choice, you should compare salaries of similar professions and factor in variables such as health benefits and potential for raises and promotions over time.